Small fish, big challenge: Filming Japan's dwarf lumpsuckers

ByHugh Miller
Cinematographer for Blue Planet III
  • Published

"Up to 2cm, nose to tail," Sarah the producer texted.

"Small, aren't they?" I'd replied rather needlessly.

I adjusted the CAD (computer-aided design) model on my computer, so it was 2cm, and sent the file to the 3D printer. I needed a physical model to get my head around the scale of the fish we were planning to film so that I could try out lenses before the shoot. It was a daunting moment – a 2cm fish was considered a whopper, most were smaller.

A male dwarf lumpsucker clings to a rock in Shizugawa Bay, Japan. Image source, BBC Studios
Image caption,

A male dwarf lumpsucker clings to a rock in Shizugawa Bay, Japan.

A giant challenge in a tiny package

Adding to the challenge, the dive site was on Japan's northeastern coast, exposed to the enormous fetch of the Pacific. The water was going to be cold, murky and dark. Searching for a fish that looks like a camouflaged broad bean in the craggy dark reefs and returning to them consistently to film was going to be difficult, to say the least. Fortunately, producer Sarah and researcher Ella had been working with Nagaaki Sato, a talented photographer and dive operator who had grown up in the area. He was willing to return to guide Shelton and I during our filming.

Even Sato-san had his work cut out, early encounters were fleeting and conditions not encouraging. The lumpsuckers were hard to find and difficult to stay with. From clinging onto the rocks, they'd take off like a bumblebee and be swept out of sight with one surge of Pacific swell.

Blue Planet III

Starts 1 November on BBC One and iPlayer

Add Blue Planet III to your Watchlist

A male dwarf lumpsucker clings to a rock in Shizugawa Bay, Japan. Image source, BBC Studios/ Nagaaki Sato
Image caption,

A male dwarf lumpsucker clings to a rock in Shizugawa Bay, Japan.

Searching the Pacific reefs

Each day we extended our dives times, acclimatising to the cold, but longer dives were not translating into better footage. Each day my heart sank a little deeper as the prospect of successfully telling the story began to slip. We talked through the problems with Sato-san. We needed to get out of the surge to work deeper, albeit with fewer fish and less light. Sato-san searched the rocky reefs, drawing on all his decades of experience to locate a good nesting hole and searching for the lumpsuckers that might be doing the same.

The nest hole he found was tiny, a squeeze, even for a small male, but opened out into a tiny chamber where the male lumpsucker could tend the female's egg. It lay quite high up from the seabed on a vertical face of rock. Too high for any of the camera grips to reach. Instead, my marinised quadpod (a type of heavy-duty underwater tripod with four legs) became a glorified anchor and step ladder. Something I could use to hook my feet into and steady myself whilst effectively handholding the camera at the nest height. It worked.

Blue Planet III Cinematographer Hugh Miller uses a specialised underwater macro camera system to film the dwarf lumpsucker.Image source, BBC Studios/ Shelton Du Preez
Image caption,

Blue Planet III Cinematographer Hugh Miller uses a specialised underwater macro camera system to film the dwarf lumpsucker, the smallest fish featured in the series, in Shizugawa Bay, Japan

Patience at the nest

The dives stacked up, and the team fell into a rhythm, cold dives were followed by some cheesy-curry-flavoured cup noodles to warm up. Add a tea-stained egg, and you have a perfect post-dive snack. Don't judge, I tried a lot of flavours, and I stand by my choice! Raeni and Thomas alternately worked as dive supervisors as their day jobs allowed, providing welcome injections of enthusiasm as they switched in and out. Ella and Sarah handled the logistics and wrangled the footage as it came off the cards. Sarah was logging and cutting a rough sequence as we went along. Weather days came and went, allowing much-needed opportunities to service gear and work on lighting solutions for the tiny hole we wanted a view of.

It's a cliché to say we were running out of time, but we were. The hatching date came and went. One day late, stretched to three days late. Three days of watching the nest and nothing.

We had a scheduled packing day before driving back to Tokyo, nobody took any persuasion to ditch it in favour of one last dive. We could pack at night, who needs sleep? Three hours into the dive, fighting the cold, thoroughly regretting that decision, an egg twitched - and the first dwarf lumpsucker hatched.

The Moment the eggs hatched

I couldn't believe it was happening. I pressed the comms button to let Shelton and topside know. I tried to stay calm, it was incredibly exciting, but the hard part was still to come. Shelton carefully secured his camera and picked up the lights, moving into a preplanned position to best highlight these tiny, impossibly cute miniatures as they hatch and then, in moments, leave the nest. The only thing left in the tiny cave was an exhausted dad who had shielded his offspring from the dangers of the outside world until they were finally ready.

Image gallerySkip image gallerySlide1 of 2, A recently hatched dwarf lumpsucker swims out of the nest, A recently hatched dwarf lumpsucker swims out of the nest.

Shelton and I both worked as hard as we could, changing setups quickly so that we could capture a lumpsucker baby on its first perilous swim. Keeping a tiny and excited grain of rice in focus took all my concentration. To create a sequence, it's essential to let it leave frame, at which point, glued to the monitor, I've no idea where it's gone. Thankfully, Shelton is masterful at keeping track of it, which allowed me to reset and get closer.

A newly hatched dwarf lumpsucker smaller than a grain of rice, in Shizugawa Bay, Japan. Image source, BBC Studios/ Nagaaki Sato
Image caption,

A newly hatched dwarf lumpsucker smaller than a grain of rice, in Shizugawa Bay, Japan.

The last hour of the last dive just flew by. Thanks to the field craft of Sato-san and the dogged persistence of the entire crew, it came together. Wildlife filmmaking doesn't always reward effort. Sometimes everything comes together; sometimes it doesn't. That's part of the job. But when it does, it's incredibly rewarding.

The lumpsucker's story is anything but small. I hope its character transcends its size. It's a remarkable fish that should light up a few hearts like it lit up mine.

Blue Planet III banner image