Analysis: Deserved win but should Anderson have been sent off?published at 22:35 BST 30 April
Nick Mashiter
Football reporter
Image source, Getty ImagesNottingham Forest deserved their win against Aston Villa, which gives them something to defend in next week's second leg - but should Elliot Anderson have been sent off?
The midfielder's first-half challenge on Ollie Watkins went unpunished but left his England team-mate in agony on the turf. Replays showed Anderson clattered into the Villa striker's ankle.
Watkins tried to get retribution later, barging into Anderson and avoiding a yellow card, but Villa may feel a sense of injustice they were not playing against 10 men.
To make matters worse for Villa, Anderson was the heartbeat of Forest's performance which earned them a justified advantage.
Would it have come had referee Joao Pinherio - or VAR - sent Anderson off?
The official then awarded them the match-winning penalty after a lengthy VAR delay following Lucas Digne's bizarre decision to raise his hands to Omari Hutchinson's hook back.
Nothing should take away from the effort and determination from Forest, though, as they extended their run to nine unbeaten games in all competitions - their best run of the season.
Crucially, they do not have to win at Villa Park next week. And while Villa will continue to be dangerous and the tie is certainly not over, it is advantage Forest.






































